Phil Emery Visits…

Melbourne, Derbyshire

Sep 16, 2024England, Derbyshire

*Words highlighted are linked to the glossary

Described as the most beautiful town of south Derbyshire by the architectural historian Nikolaus Pevsner, Melbourne has an interesting range of historic buildings reflecting most ages of English architecture (Fig 1). Its historical importance has declined since the middle ages and it is perhaps this that has allowed it to maintain a certain charm, that on a sunny day makes for an enjoyable visit without feeling you’ve been centre stage in Historic England. Or perhaps that is a little unfair. We shall see!

Church close, Melbourne, Derbyshire.

Fig 1. The church close and environs are the heart of Melbourne, Derbyshire. Here we have the quintessential English scene of medieval parish church, Georgian house and 20th century war memorial.

Melbourne’s Top Sights

A Royal Church? The Parish Church of St Michael with St Mary

Without doubt the jewel in the crown of Melbourne is its parish church. The church is surrounded by buildings that stand quite close by and an external appreciation requires a circuit with a good deal of viewing from angles. However, entering the church is a genuine wow moment.

The church had strong royal links and was given to the Bishop of Carlisle by Henry I in 1133. This royal link is probably the reason for the impressive size and layout of the church which claims, quite reasonably, to have the feel of a ‘miniature cathedral’. The status of Melbourne was much higher in the middle ages when it was a royal manor and had a substantial castle. It still formed a significant residence for the Duchy of Lancaster well into the 15th century before falling into disuse and finally being demolished in the 1630s.

Unfortunately, virtually nothing is left of the castle. However, the church was built during the period of Norman architecture in England and, possibly as a result of the relative decline of importance of Melbourne, it is still essentially a Norman church of impressive size with only modest alterations and improvements. St Michael and St Mary is a substantial church which Pevsner refers to as “the most ambitious surviving Norman parish church of England.” You can feel why immediately you enter. The distinctive circular piers with Norman capitals carry a round arched arcade with chevron (zigzag) carvings and as your gaze is drawn to the similar styled arches of the crossing, the effect is of stepping back in time to the 12th century.

Nave of Melbourne parish church

Fig 2. The nave of Melbourne parish church looking east. 12th century Norman architecture at its finest.

The church is cruciform in layout and has north and south aisles with a chancel. However, behind this simple description is a story of a church that has unique features that suggests it was built as a royal church by Henry I.

What makes Melbourne parish church unique?

When you look around the inside of the church and view the external east end it is quite clear that this was a two-tier church: a unique feature in English churches.

At the west end is a gallery (Fig 3), usually reserved for nobility. In this case, presuming it was built by Henry, it would have held his royal pew. This would have given the king the privacy afforded to royalty whilst providing an uninterrupted view along the nave. The west end below the gallery has the only stone vaulting in the church, a sign perhaps of the importance of the royal association.

Gallery of Melbourne parish church, Derbyshire.

Fig 3. It seems likely Melbourne was a royal church built by Henry I. This gallery at the west end would have held the royal pew.

​From here, walkways run along both sides of the nave above the arcade and continue around the crossing (Fig 4). These walkways gave access to an upper chancel which was for royal use; they also create a clerestory to add light to the church. The two-tier chancel was the only one in England and had the effect of creating an entire upper floor in the church exclusively for royalty.

Melbourne parish church walkway.

Fig 4. The walkway above the north arcade that linked the western gallery with the upper east chancel. Here you can still see the tripartite Norman openings. Those above the south arcade are Gothic twin openings from the 13th century.

Unfortunately, the upper chancel is no more, but its outline can be seen on the east of the crossing tower (Fig 5), where the lower central window would have been its entrance.
Melbourne parish church - Norman construction evidence

Fig 5. Every picture tells a story. The Norman construction of the original building can be seen in this photograph with the roof outline of the upper chancel on the tower. The blocked Norman arch that would have opened to the south-east transept apse and the evidence of this apse can be seen on the grassed area.

Another feature that highlighted to grandeur of Melbourne parish church is the presence of three apses at the east end. This triple apse style was typical of important Romanesque churches and the ‘squaring’ of the east end in the 14th century is one of the few post-Norman features. These now have Gothic windows. You can still see the evidence of the Norman apses both inside and outside the church.

In addition, the presence of three towers, two at the west and one over the central crossing is an indication of the importance attached to Melbourne and its royal connection. Though the western towers were not completed, they sit impressively either side of the beautifully carved central portico (Fig 6). There are a few post Norman features, notably the upper section of the tower and the aisle and eastern windows of the church. However, considering the sweeping alterations made to many churches of this style, Melbourne is a remarkably complete and fine example of a Norman church.

West facade - Melbourne parish church

Fig 6. The solidity of Norman architecture is evident in the west facade. The portico is a classic example with multiple columns, carved capitals and chevron arch.

Having looked at the layout of this impressive church, it is now worth enjoying some of the quirky features of medieval architecture, including a ‘squint’ in the Lady Chapel that gives a view of the high altar.

It is worth remembering that medieval churches were polychromatic in decoration (with brightly colours wall paintings) and rich with carvings. Sadly, many of the wall paintings in England have been lost due to the combined effects of general wear accompanied by two periods of iconoclasm during the 16th century Reformation and the English Civil War of the following century. Fortunately, a classic example of wall painting remains at Melbourne, having been saved from destruction by being hidden behind a plaque. This colourful and dramatic mural (Fig 7) is on the arch between the nave and the chancel. This was the traditional place for ‘doom paintings’ which graphically illustrated judgement day. The two women in this painting appear to have fallen short as they are portrayed with demons on their backs and are being grasped by the claws of the devil. Quite a warning for the medieval peasant!

Graphic depiction of judgement day.

Fig 7. This graphic depiction of judgement day has a cartoon like quality designed to ensure the submissiveness of the illiterate peasantry.

By contrast, some of the carvings in the church are quite humorous and don’t appear to be telling a bible story. There are quite a number of medieval mason marks, particularly near to the Lady Chapel at the north transept. These distinctive marks were an assurance for the mason to receive the correct payment for his work.

Two of the famous and more humorous carvings on capitals (Figs 8 & 9) can be found on either side of the arch as you enter the chancel. One depicts the grinning Melbourne cat whilst opposite the source of its mirth is a man trying to control his snarling dog, who would clearly like to stop the cat’s grin! Other carvings include the regularly depicted pagan fertility symbol the ‘sheela-na-gig’ and many human and animal forms. Strolling around the church examining the carvings is rewarding in itself.

Never the twain shall meet.

Fig 8. Never the twain shall meet!

Never the twain shall meet.

Fig 9. Never the twain shall meet!

Melbourne Hall Gardens

It is probably not often that a garden outshines its house, but here at Melbourne Hall, that is the case. The gardens originate from the Baroque period in England, when gardening design was heavily influenced and adapted from the most famous Baroque garden of all, that designed by Le Nôtre for Louis XIV at Versailles.

Melbourne Hall gardens are famous as the only surviving gardens of George London and Henry Wise, the royal gardeners, who championed the Baroque garden in England, and who designed the gardens here along with the then owner of the house, Sir Thomas Coke, in the early 1700s.

The formal garden lies to the east of the house (Fig 10) running down from the garden facade of the house to the ‘great basin’. The Baroque garden of this, the later Stuart period, was typified by a taming of nature as opposed to the increasingly natural styles of the Georgian. This resulted in formal geometric parterres and control over the water supply which necessitated creating a sophisticated system of hydraulics from the nearby mill pool.

Melbourne Hall Baroque gardens.

Fig 10. The formal Baroque garden with precise shapes formed by gravel paths and ‘Parterres à l’Anglaise’.

The English version of the Baroque garden which can be seen here at Melbourne has a strict geometrical design with the main axis running directly to the great basin and wrought iron arbour (Fig 11), passing symmetrically aligned topiary bushes and lead statues.

Melbourne Hall gardens arbour.

Fig 11. The Arbour situated at the far end of the garden axis.

The English love of well maintained lawns, delineated by coloured gravel paths, is referred to as ‘Parterres à l’Anglaise’ and at Melbourne these form the basis of the formal garden .The lead statues are by a famous Flemish sculptor, Jan van Nost, and are contemporary to the creation of the garden. They include figures from Greek and Roman mythology such as Perseus (Fig 12) and Andromeda and are all Grade 1 listed. Landowners never tired of associating themselves with classical culture and mythology.

Statue in Melbourne Hall gardens.

Fig 12. Perseus holding the head of Medusa.

The supposed less formal area of the garden to the south is still Baroque, with the emphasis on straight allées running from feature to feature and smaller allées radiating outwards (Fig 13).

Melbourne Hall gardens - van Nost’s Four Seasons Vase.

Fig 13. From the focal point of van Nost’s Four Seasons Vase (1705) allées radiate outwards.

The three garden ponds and their fountains are in an exact line (Fig 14) and alongside the formal garden is a long Yew tunnel (Fig 15).

Fountains at Melbourne Hall gardens.

Fig 14. The three garden pools and their fountains are perfectly aligned.

Yew tunnel at Melbourne Hall gardens.

Fig 15. The Yew Tunnel offered a shaded walkway to the less formal gardens and the kitchen gardens.

In the ‘wilderness’ garden, there are more informal plantings (Fig 16) although even here flowers and shrubs are arranged by size and the water feature is a straight canal rather than a meandering stream.

‘Wilderness’ garden at Melbourne Hall.

Fig 16. A colourful border in the ‘wilderness’ garden.

The one glaring exception to the geometrical nature of the gardens at Melbourne Hall is the failure of them to align with the central axis of the house, a situation that evidently concerned Sir Thomas Coke, but one which he had to reluctantly accept due to issues with rebuilding the house.

Melbourne Hall. A grade 2 house with a grade 1 scandal

The Hall, whilst not achieving the status of its gardens, is nevertheless of interest as much for its links to a famous scandal as for its architecture.

Melbourne Hall has close links to two famous 19th century Prime Ministers. Lord Palmerston, Prime Minister under Queen Victoria, was married to Emily Lamb, who inherited Melbourne in 1853. However, it was Emily’s eldest brother William, Lord Melbourne (Victoria’s first Prime Minister), whose marriage to Lady Caroline was to create a famous scandal in 19th century British society. Lady Caroline Lamb’s tumultuous affair with the poet Lord Byron, who she famously described as ‘mad, bad, and dangerous to know’, was to destroy her marriage to William and resulted in her being banished to Melbourne Hall in 1825. The city of Melbourne in Australia was named in honour of Lord Melbourne by Queen Victoria with whom William had a close relationship.

Melbourne Hall visitors entrance.

Fig 17. The south and visitors entrance to the Hall facing Melbourne Pool.

Melbourne Hall (Fig 17) is a family home and as such access to the rooms is restricted and internal photography not permitted. However, the guides are knowledgeable and an inexpensive guidebook provides photographs and layouts.

The house today has, as its core, a building from before the English Civil War. The Coke family identified with Charles I during these tumultuous years and, following the success of the Parliamentarians, fled to France, living in exile until the restoration of Charles II in 1660. The bulk of the house is 18th century with the garden facade to the east being the most pleasingly Georgian (Fig 18). This front of ashlar stone is seven bays wide with a three bay pediment decorated with garlands and a coat of arms. The ground floor windows and doors have rusticated surrounds and above the central doorway is a pediment. It is of a pleasing symmetry, crying out to be in harmonious alignment with the gardens. However, as we have seen, this was not to be, although looking out from the Staircase Hall you can understand Thomas’ concerns.

Melbourne Hall's Georgian East facade.

Fig 18. The Georgian East facade offset from the gardens.

The internal tour of the house begins in the billiard room which is an addition to the south and main visitor entrance. The tour takes in dining room and the main reception rooms along the east wing of the house.

The Best of the Rest

The Cathedral Close and Melbourne Pool

The impressive lake that faces the visitors’ entrance to the hall is Melbourne Pool. It was originally a medieval millpond with a water mill and miller’s house. These are all still present but the pond, mill and house were substantially altered in the 19th century. It is still an enjoyable place to walk and has the advantage of affording a picturesque view of the town from the far side (Fig 19).

Far side of Melbourne Pool

Fig 19. The view of the town from the far side of Melbourne Pool.

Close by the church are the Tudor style 19th century vicarage next to Stone House which has rubble walls from the 17th century. The Tithe barn by the west end of the church has been much altered over the years but has 14th century origins and has massive blocks of stone and rubble in its lower courses. To the north of the church is the Georgian Close House (Fig 1). The rest of the town can be enjoyed on foot and has an interesting and eclectic range of buildings including several thatched cottages.

Thatched cottage in Melbourne, Derbyshire

Fig 20. The eclectic range of buildings in Melbourne includes this charming thatched cottage from 16th century

Melbourne Hall Stables and Cottages

The entry to Melbourne Hall gardens is through this attractive courtyard across from the church. This is a delightful space to enjoy refreshments, which are not available in the hall, gardens or church. Here are three or four options including a tea room, a craft beer bar in the stables (Fig 21) along with gift shops.

Melbourne Hall stables courtyard

Fig 21. The Stables Courtyard is an ideal place for refreshments and includes Stable Ales, a craft beer taproom.

Is Melbourne worth visiting?

The main historic attractions of Melbourne are centred round the parish church and Melbourne Hall and gardens. The church is spectacular and the gardens relaxing and informative. The best view of the hall is from the gardens, although from a distance. House tours are restricted by it being a family home and consequently are only available for certain days during the month of August. However, the gardens are open from Spring to Autumn on certain days from 1pm – 5pm.Melbourne is well worth visiting to savour the Norman church but it is best to plan ahead to find a time when the gardens are open. The Melbourne Hall website has full details of opening times.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

News

Latest Posts