Phil Emery Visits…

Rievaulx Abbey & Byland Abbey: A Corner of North Yorkshire Forever Cistercian

Nov 23, 2023England, North Yorkshire, Yorkshire

*Words highlighted are linked to the glossary

North Yorkshire Moors

In the south west corner of the North Yorkshire Moors, in bucolic wooded valleys are two picturesque ruins: Rievaulx Abbey and Byland Abbey. The English seem to love a good ruin and these two Cistercian Abbeys are among the most impressive ruined monastic foundations in England. Whether it’s the mystery of romantic medieval times with tonsured monks, rich tales of border raids and visitations of the Black Death or possibly their ultimate destruction by a famous Tudor king, the passion for these ruins dates back to at least the early 18th century. These two sites experienced rises and falls that contain many elements of English history and as they are now both in the care of English Heritage, they are open to visitors.

Who were the Cistercians?

The Cistercians and their order of White Monks (called so because of their white robes) were founded in 1098 at Citeaux in Burgundy with the intention of adhering more closely to the Rule of St Benedict. St Benedict had set the standards for monastic life in the sixth century but the belief that standards had slipped led to a reforming zeal that came to be led by the Cistercian order. The Cistercian movement grew rapidly and by the mid 12th century well over 300 Cistercian Abbeys had been founded throughout Europe. Rievaulx and Byland Abbeys were part of this growth which led to more than 80 Cistercian monasteries in England and eight major monastic sites in Yorkshire. The monasteries housed lay brothers as well as monks. The lay brothers undertook the physical labour within the monastic community leaving the better educated and usually higher social status monks to spend their days in study and prayer. The layout of the Cistercian monasteries of Rievaulx and Byland included substantial buildings to house these lay brethren.

Rievaulx Abbey

Founded in 1132 by Walter Espec of nearby Helmsley Castle, Rievaulx is situated in this idyllic wooded valley of the River Rye (Fig 1). It was chosen for its remoteness along with the need for fresh water and agricultural land. The lay of the land led to the church being aligned more northwest to southeast rather than the traditional east-west, although here for descriptive purposes the site is assumed to be east-west. From only twelve monks at this time, the new monastery grew rapidly to house well over 600 at its peak later in the century. In addition, there were a body of lay brothers who helped with the everyday running of the abbey. The monks diverted the course of the river to provide fresh water for their needs, which included washing, cooking and brewing.

Rievaulx Abbey in the valley of the River Rye

Fig 1. Rievaulx Abbey in the valley of the River Rye.

Unlike neighbouring Byland, substantial ruins remain at Rievaulx and the monastic church is clearly visible. However, the western arm of the church has suffered the most and has been virtually raised to the ground. Constructed during the Romanesque or Norman period, it would have been entered at the western end through the Galilee porch where the floor still retains some 13th century tiling. It is still possible to identify the nave with its two aisles from the remains of the rough, darker stone of the substantial piers. Architectural historians have been able to deduce that the main nave was barrel vaulted in wood whist the aisles had similar style vaulting in stone. This would have been the section of the church utilized by the lay brethren.

Looking along the nine bays of the nave, eastwards to the transepts (the north and south arms of the church), it is possible to see the change in style from the coarser stonework of the round arched Norman church to the lighter more refined stonework of the pointed windows of the later Gothic east end (Figs 2 & 3).

The view along the Romanesque nave to the transepts of Rievaulx Abbey

Fig 2. The view along the Romanesque nave to the transepts.

The transepts of Rievaulx Abbey

Fig 3. In the transepts, the change from round arched Norman architecture to the pointed arch of Gothic can be seen.

The eastern arm of the church, or Presbytery, was rebuilt about 1230 during the architectural period known as Early English Gothic. The east end contained the High Altar and was the most important part of the church. It would have been partitioned from the nave by a Rood screen. Here would be located the most valuable relics and shrines as well as being the focal point of worship. This saw an extensive remodelling of the Norman church with a new seven bay aisled Gothic presbytery, three stories high, that provided a fitting place for a shrine. Rievaulx’s most famous Abbott, Aelred, was canonised as a saint in 1250 and this magnificent Gothic presbytery may have been intended for the veneration of his relics.

The Presbytery of Rievaulx Abbey

Fig 4. The Presbytery showing the use of lancet windows in the eastern wall with the three storeys of arcade, triforium and clerestory at either side. The composite piers of the arcade are slender than those in the nave. Also showing is the location of the High Altar.

The Eastern end of Rievaulx Abbey

Fig 5. The eastern end. Visible are the southern aisle to the left which has a lancet and the remains of a flying buttress in the more ruined north aisle.

One of the main features of Early English Gothic was tall, slender pointed windows known as ‘lancets’. These feature most spectacularly at the east end of the church where one can still see two groups of three lancets (Fig 4). The pointed arch proved better in coping with the huge weight of these buildings as did the addition of flying buttresses, which were basically props to prevent the walls splaying out under the weight of the masonry (Fig 5).

The opulence of this building, and indeed that of nearby Byland, must have seemed in conflict with the austerity preached by the Cistercians, but it was in part justified by the desire to provide a fitting shrine for the worship of saintly relics. The resulting church would have rivalled any cathedral and certainly qualifies as a great church.

Subsequently, many ruined abbeys were used as ‘eye catchers’ by the owners of Country Houses such as befell nearby Fountains, or settings for Romantic painters like JMW Turner.

The rest of the monastery, comprising accommodation for the monks and lay brethren is in various states of disrepair but can be explored leisurely. The cloisters to the south of the church are still identifiable and a part of the arcading has been restored to give an idea of the structure. The most impressive remaining structure is the refectory. The floor of this building would have been at the same level as the cloisters and flanked by a warming house and kitchen, with a lavery for the monks to wash their hands prior to entering (Figs 6 & 7).

Entrance to The Refectory, Rievaulx Abbey

Fig 6. The entrance to the Refectory. The monks would wash in the lavery under the arches to either side. This again shows the contrast between the lower rounded Norman work and the pointed Gothic style above.

The Refectory, Rievaulx Abbey

Fig 7. The Refectory with an arcade running around the three walls, of which there is some blind arcading between the windows.

The rest of the monastic complex, including infirmary and chapter house, is well signposted. The unusual apsidal church like chapter house is still visible in layout and was the heart beat of the community. The windows here had much later Perpendicular Gothic tracery from the 14th century. There is a small onsite museum with examples of carvings from the various periods of building and a well presented shop and cafe.

Byland Abbey

Byland Abbey is in a much more ruinous state than Rievaulx and as a result the facilities here are much sparser than at Rievaulx. The site is often unmanned and so the visitor is encouraged to follow the sign posted features (Fig 8).

The ruins of Byland Abbey from the north

Fig 8. The ruins of Byland Abbey from the north.

The monastic community at Byland had led a peripatetic existence for over forty years before arriving at this site and beginning work on their new church. The west range, which housed the lay brothers, had been built a little earlier, but it was the church itself that was to be the jewel in the crown of Byland. Begun about 1170, it coincided with the arrival from France of the Gothic style, first witnessed in St Denis Paris in the 1140s. Viewing the ruins today it is hard to believe that Byland was the most ambitious Cistercian church of 12th century Europe. In size it would have exceeded many medieval cathedrals.

The western facade, Byland Abbey

Fig 9. The western facade of Byland Abbey.

So much of Byland is now lost, particularly the arcaded walls of the nave and the central tower, which collapsed after the dissolution of the monasteries in Tudor times. However, this three storey cruciform (the church plan was the shape of a cross with the nave at the west forming the long leg, the north and south transepts the arms, and the presbytery with the high altar the upper part) Gothic church was very important in the north of England, influencing the nearby abbeys of Whitby and Rievaulx and also York Minster, where the rose window in the south transept was based on that of the west elevation of Byland (Fig 9). The western facade is the largest remaining feature of the abbey church and the three large lancets were once surmounted by a large rose window, the lower outline of which can be seen.

The nave would have comprised arcade, gallery and clerestory. Excavations have shown that when built it was limewashed inside and lavishly painted. Excavated stonework displays carving of the highest quality and tiling from later in the abbey’s life can still be found in the south transept (Fig 10).

Much of what is known today is largely due to drawings from the early 1800s. Decay was gradual, but hastened by the site being used as a quarry for local building. The south transept, for example, is known to have collapsed in 1822 but was fortunately recorded by earlier artists.

The south transept, Byland Abbey

Fig 10. The south transept with the medieval tiling. On the far wall is the remains of a piscina or washing bowl.

The rest of the abbey precinct is easy to explore as it is well signposted. Two major buildings, typical of all monastic settlements, are easily identifiable: the cloister, which would have been of two storeys with the monks’ dormitory on the upper floor, and the chapter house where the daily business of the abbey was conducted, located near to the south transept.

Another building of note, but now equally ruined, is the Abbot’s lodging. This would have resembled a typical medieval hall found in castles and homes of the nobility, evidence of the financial power of these monastic institutions prior to the reformation.

Raids, Plague and Royalty

In choosing a remote and idyllic location, an abbey could be left exposed to danger of attack and still not be able to avoid disease and pestilence.

One famous incident occurred in 1322 whilst King Edward ll was staying at Rievaulx with his wife, Queen Isabella. English forces were surprised and routed by a Scottish raiding party led by Robert the Bruce. Edward was forced to flee and in so doing abandoned the royal treasure which was gleefully seized by the marauding Scots, who then pillaged the abbey and that of Byland as well.

The Bubonic Plague, or Black Death as it came to be called was much feared in medieval Europe and a particularly virulent case in 1348 decimated the English population, killing approximately half the population. The remoteness of Rievaulx and Byland proved no barrier; by the 1370s only 15 monks and 3 lay brothers remained at Rievaulx and only 11 monks and 3 lay brothers at Byland.

Dissolution, Suppression and Henry VIII

In 1532, the Pope refused to annul the marriage of Henry Vlll and Catherine of Aragon, resulting in Henry having a monumental outburst (about which all school children have been taught). This outburst morphed into the English Reformation, which embraced some of the zeal of the European Reformation. When Henry suppressed (shut down) some smaller monasteries, rebellion broke out in the North of England. Known as the Pilgrimage of Grace, the rebellion was brutally put down by Henry, who then proceeded to suppress the remaining larger monasteries including Rievaulx and Byland.

It is a moot point as to how much the English Reformation was a fit of pique by Henry, who couldn’t abide not getting his own way, and how much was a genuine question of faith. Whatever the reason, the dissolution of the monasteries was a big pay day for the king. The abbots and monks of Rievaulx and Byland both surrendered their abbeys to Henry’s Suppression Commissioners and received pensions. The monasteries were then gutted of any valuables, had their roofs removed to render them unusable and sold by the king to allies who could then gain a return on their investment by selling off anything that was left. So began their decline to a ruinous state.

Picturesque and modern

Post Reformation, English Monasteries became romanticised as picturesque locations. Land owners in the 18th century became interested in the wonder of medieval England and a ‘Gothick’ fascination with ruins grew. For example, Rievaulx became a picturesque location to be viewed from a terrace on the hillside built by the owners of nearby Duncombe Park. A similar fate fell to nearby Fountains Abbey.

In the 19th century, the ruins of abbeys became of interest historically and architecturally; they consequently became places to visit and appreciate. Landscape painters, including Turner, used them for settings.

In the 20th century, this recognition of their place in English history resulted in them being placed in the care of preservation organisations; in the case of Rievaulx and Byland, this was English Heritage.

1 Comment

  1. Julie Watkinson

    Thank you Phil, found that very interesting, it’s a long time since visiting both but didn’t know all the history behind

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

News

Latest Posts